Well (sigh) this is basically Pokémon Gold but just an amazing remake of it!The creator(Zel) took his time and put in a lot of effort to make this hack lay ed out to the T, just like original Gold. The only minor difference I noticed was  that this is an  incomplete hack and if you verse a certain trainer in kanto in this game,( no matter if you beat the trainer or not)the game brings you back to the main menu. Another difference I noticed was the new rival named Carlos that's in this hack and also Pokémon evolve by stones or levels instead of trade or friendship!
Graphics I felt deserved a 10 simply because they are based off of Pokémon Firered, and therefore the best he had to work with at the time.
Sound I gave a 9 because they are the same as the original sound from Gold, and are unchanged, as well as the Pokémon's battle cries.
Addictiveness I gave a 9 because I would definitely play this hack again to simply enjoy a well, up to date in color version of Gold, and it's not that long of a hack so it would be a simple fast journey to replay so that means its less time consuming.
Story I gave an 8 because its the exact same as original Gold and I enjoyed that story very much because it have 16 gyms in it and it was a good story that introduced something new and this hack introduced Carlos which was kinda a challenge but he wasn't to hard.
Depth I gave a 7 because this is an incomplete hack but it does have a purpose to playing after you beat the elite four for johto, you go to kanto and beat kantos gym's and catch the legendary birds and you can pursue the legendary dogs.
Difficulty I gave a 5 because its really not that difficult of a game, no trainers levels of Pokémon were boosted/edited, that goes for gym leaders Pokémon, elite 4's Pokémon as well. And quite frankly it was a nice and easy game were you could beat it at your own pace, and for you old school Pokémon players like me take it nice and easy and enjoy an older school game on a Pokémon Firered graphic and color wise platform!

Did someone just say "Old school pokémon players"? That got my attention! lol Loving how you break the categories down. Keep up the good work. Unfortunately, I've never played the original, so I failed to get the referrences, though most who would play a hack would have already played the original. Anyway, looking forward to seeing how you step it up again next time!

marcus047 : good job on this review. It's decent and has good detail. It's short but good.

This is a decent review to me.

I do like that you broke the game into sections but it feels like you didn't fill enough details for the graphics. It is short and simple which some people like but game reviews are supposed to be a little more detailed. What if some people who read this game review have not played any of the Pokemon games at all? You should mention the gameplay of the game as well.

I have played part of this hack before and I like the adjustments that the creator of the game has made. I agree with you on that part.

Put a little more detail to your future reviews and they would increase the quality of your reviews. Other than that, this review is okay in overall to me.